pvgool said:
It is very unlikely that the editor who will do the review of your site will be reading your postings at R-Z. Only the site itself will be evaluated, on itself it will have to prove that it is listable.
I'm afraid that won't happen. How many people would be asking for favors like this if we were going to do site reviews on request.
We (almost) never tell the reason why a site is rejected. From our experience we know it is almost of no use to do so (99,99% of rejected sites can not be changed to meet the DMOZ requirements) and if we do it will often only result in very negative reseponses.
I believe that my site is being rejected automatically (before it is evaluated by the editor).
I am not asking that you look at my site but rather check the dmoz side. It is my responsibility that the site meet the rules set by dmoz. While I fully understand that acceptance is not gauranteed, It seems to me that if a site meets the requirements laid out by dmoz then it should be reviewed by an editor.
In the link listed above the site was rejected, rightfully so, because it was a mirror. The site that was rejected was usedmachines.biz. I explained the best I could in that discussion how this had happened. It has since been taken care of. I do not know how dmoz works nor am I asking you to reveal any secrets, but if it is being automatically rejected based on a mistake made over a year ago then I am asking that something be done that will allow the site to make it to the stage where it will be reviewed by an editor.
