It should not matter if the links are affiliate/partner links or not. They are valid links to real/major stores listed in my mega mall. My site is a true shopping directory and should qualify for listing. I don't understand the criterias for ineligibility.
I reviewed the sites listed under the dmoz/shopping/directories and I can NOT figure out how some of those sites have been qualified as shopping directories. I found some that are just like mine but they have been accepted and mine is being denied. I found some that don't exist anymore and some others that have tons of broken links. I start wondering about the quality of this directory. Anyway, Here is my assessment of the existing listing under the dmoz/shopping/directories category: (my comments as preceded by >>>>)
Current dmoz/shopping/directories Lisitng:
===============================
1. African American Shopping Mall - An index of sites selling Afrocentric merchandise.
>>>> SHOPPING DIRECTORY SAME AS MINE -- SOME BROKEN LINKS
2. Americana Annies - Offers a selection of crafts, candles, collectibles, and gifts.
>>>> THIS IS NOT A SHOPPING DIRECTORY
3. AOL Shopping - Shop online for favorite brands and stores.
>>>> THIS SITE DOES NOT EXIST
4. BabyBusiness.com - Designed to help consumers find information on products and dealers in the baby business. Includes product recall information.
>>>> THIS IS A STORE AND NOT A SHOPPING DIRECTORY.
5. Bronze.net - Provides a retail directory of bronze fine art galleries and manufactured items.
>>>> THIS IS NOT A SHOPPING DIRECTORY
6. Buyersguide - Direct links to products and services in nine major categories.
>>>> MAY QUALIFY AS A DIRECTORY -- TONS OF BROKEN LINKS.
7. ClothingDirectories.com - Clothing, footwear and accessory listings.
>>>> MAY QUALIFY AS A DIRECTORY -- TONS OF BROKEN LINKS
8. The Den Mall - Offers a variety of merchandise for home, garden, health, and gifts.
>>>> LOOKS MORE LIKE A STORE THAN A SHOPPING DIRECTORY.
9. EZ2Rent.com - Listings of available rentals of real estate, vehicles, appliances, and all manner of equipment; item description, owner contact information, and online ordering available.
>>>> THIS IS DEFINITELY NOT A SHOPPING DIRECTORY
10. Farmer's Market Online - Buy produce, specialty foods, crafts, gifts and books direct from producers in the U.S. and Canada.
>>>> THIS IS A STORE AND NOT A DIRECTORY.
11. FingerTipShopper.com - Shopping mall featuring thousands of fashion, leisure, travel, business, houseware, home improvement and health products.
>>>> THIS IS A SHOPPING MALL SAME LIKE MINE.
12. Froogle - Google's product search engine and shopping directory. Assists consumers with locating products for sale online by presenting photos of relevant products and links to the stores that sell them.
>>>> SHOPPING SEARCH ENGINE, QUALIFY AS A DIRECTORY
13. Galaxy Mall - Directory of stores in a variety of categories. Also offers classifieds and listing new shops.
>>>> THIS IS NOT A DIRECTORY
14. Information Services - Provides listings of online shopping malls and other shopping directories.
>>>> SHOPPING DIRECTORY SAME AS MINE
15. Internet Store List - International directory including thousands of online shopping stores.
>>>> SHOPPING DIRECTORY SAME AS MINE
16. Jorbins.com - Directory of online shopping sites and magazine articles.
>>>> THIS A MAGAZINE DIRECTORY AND NOT A SHOPPING DIRECTORY
17. MSN eShop - Shopping tools including product guides, gift finder and gift certificates and links to online shopping sites with special offers.
>>>> SHOPPING DIRECTORY SAME AS MINE
18. NetShoppers - Indexing ecommerce websites of the US, Canada and the World with resources for auctions, shopping malls and ecommerce sites.
>>>> SHOPPING DIRECTORY SAME AS MINE.
19. Point Shop - Offering a broad variety of products and services including sports, automotive, food, and jewelry.
>>>> I AM NOT SURE IF THIS IS A STORE OR A DIRECTORY ?
20. The Safety Search - Online shopping with merchants graded and tested for security.
>>>> SHOPPING DIRECTORY SAME AS MINE.
21. Search Gift Baskets - Directory of gift basket companies by state.
>>>> A (SPECIALTY) SHOPPING DIRECTORY.
21. Shop Search
>>>> SHOPPING DIRECTORY SAME AS MINE.