http://www.holisticpetsupplies.co.uk

Please let me know the status of http://www.holisticpetsupplies.co.uk, submitted to:


1. http://dmoz.org/Shopping/Pets/Supplies/
2. http://dmoz.org/Shopping/Pets/Dogs/
3.http://dmoz.org/Shopping/Pets/Health/

Thank you.

Several duplicate or inappropriate submittals have been deleted, including both 1) and 2). I don't see it in #3, but apparently there is at least one more submittal waiting review (the log only shows where it isn't any more, not where it still is.)

Should I resubmit to no 3?

If 1 & 2 duplicate submittals have been deleted, do you mean that the original submittal should be listed and only the duplicates deleted? Or if these submittals were deleted because they were inappropriate, do you mean they were inappropriate for this category as the site does not contain any illegal content?

Should I check back once pending submittal has been reviewed before resubmitting no 3?

Thank you,

Holistic

Inappropriate for the category only. I don't know that a determination has been made on whether the site is eligible for listing at all, so I'm tentatively assuming it might be.

If you resubmit, look at the subcategories of Health; I think you can find a more specific topic that fits the site.

It probably would do no harm, and might even help, to resubmit to a subcategory of Health.

Thank you!

Thank you Hutcheson, I will resubmit to pets/health....

My site also sells dog/cat beds, toys and treats, and collars/leads as well as supplements for health. I thought that pets/supplies and pets/dogs were the most appropriate categories so I think that it must have been deleted because the site was not eligible for listing. Where can I find info on eligibility?

Thanks again,

Holistic

What's the one category that most closely matches the focus of the site?

A few outlying products doesn't change the focus. If you sell, say, 100 different flavors of fractionally distilled dog poison and one style of handcrafted jewelled rat collar, then the site isn't going to be listed under "generic pets" or "supplies" -- it's still going to be under Dog Food.

If you aren't absolutely clear that you have found the one site that best fits, then DO NOT RESUBMIT. The editors already have a submittal: if they have to find the right place for it, then you've already done all that you can do, so stop. Again, the ONLY reason for resubmitting is if you are SURE that you KNOW the ONE right category, because you KNOW a GOOD reason why EVERY other category is not plausible.