Help!
I am a huge Open Source fan, and so I thought I would contribute some time to being an editor. I've listed numerous sites at dmoz.org before, and I've always wanted to come help out.
I finally had the time to apply as an editor yesterday, so I picked a fairly small category that I'm familiar with, bicycle racing, and offered my services. The last part of the application, however, asked me to suggest 2 or 3 sites that I would add to the category. Now, I made a site for a friend that holds a bicycle race every year, so I listed his site, but I didn't feel right listing any other sites, without permission from their owner.
I later received an email stating that I was rejected because I only listed ONE site, and it was one I designed.
I don't understand the purpose of that. I thought an editor would be editing things, not adding things. I don't want to add someone's website to the dmoz without making sure they understand what I'm doing first. Some people don't want a million hits a day. Some people, especially small bike races, host on small servers that are used for local people to access for information.
Why is ADDING websites that I don't control, part of applying to become an editor? When I look up the word editor, it seems to mean something different. I was just trying to help. I'm sorry, but I don't understand. I read the guidelines, and I don't see where it told me that ADDing sites was critical to my application. I can understand if you want me to find sites and add them AFTER I'm approved as an editor, but to require people to randomly pick sites, without authorization, and add them to the dmoz seems "not right". What am I missing?
dazed and confused
I am a huge Open Source fan, and so I thought I would contribute some time to being an editor. I've listed numerous sites at dmoz.org before, and I've always wanted to come help out.
I finally had the time to apply as an editor yesterday, so I picked a fairly small category that I'm familiar with, bicycle racing, and offered my services. The last part of the application, however, asked me to suggest 2 or 3 sites that I would add to the category. Now, I made a site for a friend that holds a bicycle race every year, so I listed his site, but I didn't feel right listing any other sites, without permission from their owner.
I later received an email stating that I was rejected because I only listed ONE site, and it was one I designed.
I don't understand the purpose of that. I thought an editor would be editing things, not adding things. I don't want to add someone's website to the dmoz without making sure they understand what I'm doing first. Some people don't want a million hits a day. Some people, especially small bike races, host on small servers that are used for local people to access for information.
Why is ADDING websites that I don't control, part of applying to become an editor? When I look up the word editor, it seems to mean something different. I was just trying to help. I'm sorry, but I don't understand. I read the guidelines, and I don't see where it told me that ADDing sites was critical to my application. I can understand if you want me to find sites and add them AFTER I'm approved as an editor, but to require people to randomly pick sites, without authorization, and add them to the dmoz seems "not right". What am I missing?
dazed and confused