Missing listing

swyzzlemark

Member
Joined
Oct 11, 2010
Messages
6
I periodically search DMOZ for my site, suggested about a 1 1/2 yrs ago, to see if it has been included - which produces no results. I just did a google search for "dmoz" and <the site name>. Strangely, that produced a web page that appears to contain dmoz listing information for my company. I can provide the link to the page if you'd like. Is my site actually in the DMOZ database but producing no results?

The DMOZ category on the page is empty. I wonder if that's why a DMOZ search produces no results? It looked like this, except I have removed the identifying information:

Dmoz: YES
Dmoz Tile: <my company name>
Dmoz Description: <my company description>
Dmoz Category: <empty category>

Also, I recently re-submitted the site, thinking something may have gotten lost.
 

pvgool

kEditall/kCatmv
Curlie Meta
Joined
Oct 8, 2002
Messages
10,093
DMOZ search is not properly equiped to find a website.
The best way to find a site is to search for domain.tld ( like dmoz.org ) do not include "http:// " , "www" or anything after the tld
 

swyzzlemark

Member
Joined
Oct 11, 2010
Messages
6
DMOZ search is not properly equiped to find a website.
The best way to find a site is to search for domain.tld ( like dmoz.org ) do not include "http:// " , "www" or anything after the tld

Thanks for the prompt response. I did the search as domain.tld and also domain. I'm sure I've also tried www and http://, etc., but never get a result. If you want to try it, use the first seven letters of my username, either with or without .com appended.

I take it by your response that you believe the search should have produced a response.

I have two specific questions:
1) is my company actually in the database?
2) if so, does the record include a category?

My concern is that if it is in the database and has no category it will never be found.
 

jimnoble

DMOZ Meta
Joined
Mar 26, 2002
Messages
18,915
Location
Southern England
I take it by your response that you believe the search should have produced a response.
It probably did - but search can sometimes be a few days out of sync with the directory. pvgool was merely pointing you at your best option.

I'm sure you've read the Discontinuation of site status checks announcement at the top of this forum so you already know that we aren't going to do a specific status check for you.
 

pvgool

kEditall/kCatmv
Curlie Meta
Joined
Oct 8, 2002
Messages
10,093
I have two specific questions:
1) is my company actually in the database?
2) if so, does the record include a category?

My concern is that if it is in the database and has no category it will never be found.
A site can only be listed in a category.


I did try to recreate your search on Google. And I see what you did wrong.
Search for "yourname" and dmoz does bring up a number of sites that claim to put values on webistes. Most of these websites do a very bad job.
If you want to use Google to serach for somthing in DMOZ you must use: "yourname" site:dmoz.org
This will search only on DMOZ pages. And the resulty is: Your search - "yourname" site:dmoz.org - did not match any documents.
Ofcourse I used your website name instead of "youname"



 

swyzzlemark

Member
Joined
Oct 11, 2010
Messages
6
A site can only be listed in a category.


I did try to recreate your search on Google. And I see what you did wrong.
Search for "yourname" and dmoz does bring up a number of sites that claim to put values on webistes. Most of these websites do a very bad job.
If you want to use Google to serach for somthing in DMOZ you must use: "yourname" site:dmoz.org
This will search only on DMOZ pages. And the resulty is: Your search - "yourname" site:dmoz.org - did not match any documents.
Ofcourse I used your website name instead of "youname"

@pvgool
Thank you for following up. If I understand correctly, doing a search for a domain and "dmoz" will produce sites with information represented as coming from dmoz that actually are not. Either searching on dmoz.org or doing a Google search for domain with site:dmoz.org is the correct way to find the listing.

@jimnoble
I had, in fact, read the Discontinuation of site status checks notice and understood completely. However, with the evidence pointing to my listing possibly being in limbo - that is, listed, but not findable - I saw no alternative. As a problem-solver, I'm sure you understand.

Anyway, you both have been very helpful. We'll sit tight.
 
This site has been archived and is no longer accepting new content.
Top