Multiple Submissions for Websites - Naming?

J

janicewuttke

When submitting one website into multiple categories (eg. regional/miami/arts & ent; news; sports, etc), is it more effective to name each submission per category to reflect that category? ie. Market.com - News; or Market.com - Sports rather than just "Market.com" for each category? Help!
 

John_Caius

Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2003
Messages
584
The best approach is to find the one best category that fits your site. If your site is Fruit Weekly then it's better to submit to the Fruit/News category rather than Fruit/Apples/News and Fruit/Oranges/News and Fruit/Bananas/News.

If you've really got very extensive content that is worthy of deeplinking, such as for example http://www.bbc.co.uk , then multiple submission of deeplinks may be appropriate, but you should probably apply for the main site listing first and perhaps ask the opinion of editors here on your specific site.

Hope that helps. :)
 
J

janicewuttke

Thank you! How do I ask the opinion of the editors? Some of the sites I have been asked to list have been done (the one that was named by subcategory in my example) - the others I did without the subcategory were not ... Would love the feedback -- Didn't think this is the forum for displaying particular website names. If I am incorrect, please let me know!
 

motsa

Curlie Admin
Joined
Sep 18, 2002
Messages
13,294
>> How do I ask the opinion of the editors?

You tell us the URLs of the sites you're thinking about submitting to multiple categories and what categories you're thinking of submitting them to. Then we'll tell you whether it's a good idea or not.
 
J

janicewuttke

Thank you --

The following are the websites I need to submit in the following categories:

US/State/Metro Areas/City
- Arts & Entertainment; Business & Economy; Education; Employment; Employment; Gov't; Guides & Dir; Health; Maps & Views; News & Media; Real Estate; Rec & Sports; Shopping; Society & Culture; Transportation; Travel & Tourism; Weather

The following websites (some do not apply to all categories if all categories do not exist):
www.Miami.com; www.Ohio.com; www.TwinCities.com; www.Charlotte.com; www.Miami.com; www.KansasCity.com and about 15 others ...

www.Philly.com has been entered into dmoz.org with a different naming mechanism -- www.Philly.com - Arts & Entertainment, and so on.

Please let me know if these categories are appropriate for these websites or if you have any other suggestions.

Thank you!
 

hutcheson

Curlie Meta
Joined
Mar 23, 2002
Messages
19,136
Looks like you're submitting websites for all the individual local newspapers in a chain. So far, so good (and thanks).

But each local newspaper's website should be listed only ONCE, and that in the News & Media category.

In very very unusual circumstances, a Newspaper site may have a "featured attraction" subsite that corresponds to an ODP category. I'd look at these three criteria to decide whether to "deeplink" that page:

1) Ordinary expectations -- every newspaper has stuff about local arts, politics, weather, business, culture, etc. We don't have to waste our time deeplinking for such obvious content.
2) Taxonomic continuity -- if the categories proposed for the deeplinks are "close" to the category containing the main listing, then there is very little value to listing the deeplinks. They would then have to be extraordinarily valuable content (as well as unexpected).
3) Specific focus -- If a newspaper sponsored a significant subsite (more than a mini-site!) on a very specific topic (such as a historical person, organization, etc.) that wasn't either immediately obvious or taxonomically nearby, then that might be worth considering for a deeplink. Hypothetical example: Flagstaff, Arizona paper building a tourist guide to the Grand Canyon (which is not taxonomically near, nor yet the normal practice of local papers, and yet of sufficient interest to have its own category.) Sacramento newspaper containing a significant tribute to, say, Bret Harte (in Literature). Nashville newspaper sponsoring a section aimed at schoolchildren on Tennessee history (in Education).

The situation you describe really fails all three tests. (But we do thank you for submitting these, and please do not neglect to submit also to the proper subcategory of http://dmoz.org/News/Newspapers/Regional/United_States/ .)
 
This site has been archived and is no longer accepting new content.
Top