Questionable link

Dirtydisco · Oct 22, 2005

http://search.dmoz.org/cgi-bin/search?search=internet+radio

link 19 goes to a links page ? that same link is repeated further on also voice overs are hardly internet radio

Internet radio :- A site that plays live or archived music or chat.

A lot of the links are poor in this listing as a whole

wjcampbe · Oct 22, 2005

I have not looked at the provided link, so the response below is generic.

We do content, not quality. Have another look and answer the editor's question - what is the one thng that is unique about this site?

When reviewing a site, I do not check every link on every page, but do check enough to find the unique content, ensure the site is basically functional, and get information for the guideline compliant description.

If you feel that a site has been placed in the wrong category, go to that category and use the Update Listing link at the top of the page to report your concerns. An editor with permissions in that area (there are around 200 editors who can edit everywhere in the directory) will look at the report and take appropriate action - which might be to do nothing - if s/he believes the listing is correct as is.

Dirtydisco · Oct 22, 2005

wjcampbe said:
I have not looked at the provided link, so the response below is generic.

We do content, not quality. Have another look and answer the editor's question - what is the one thng that is unique about this site?

When reviewing a site, I do not check every link on every page, but do check enough to find the unique content, ensure the site is basically functional, and get information for the guideline compliant description.

If you feel that a site has been placed in the wrong category, go to that category and use the Update Listing link at the top of the page to report your concerns. An editor with permissions in that area (there are around 200 editors who can edit everywhere in the directory) will look at the report and take appropriate action - which might be to do nothing - if s/he believes the listing is correct as is.

I will help you or the editor concerned http://search.about.com is not an internet radio its a general directory and the link in question that information is being pulled to be listed is spam

wjcampbe · Oct 22, 2005

I will help you or the editor concerned

Unfortunately this does not help.

Resource Zone is not DMOZ (aka ODP) but a place for discussion about the project. The way to raise a concern about a listing is explained above, but I will repeat it here.

go to that category and use the Update Listing link at the top of the page

Alucard · Oct 22, 2005

Dirtydisco,

The one site that you highlighted is obviously a page that is no longer available, and I have removed it from the directory - thank you very much for the heads-up! (It won't disppear from the search results until they are updated, which might take a while.)

pvgool · Oct 22, 2005

Resource Zone is not DMOZ (aka ODP) but a place for discussion about the project. The way to raise a concern about a listing is explained above, but I will repeat it here.

This answer is not completely true.
It is possible to let us know about misplaced or wrong sites through R-Z. We have a special thread Report Hijacks, Dead Links & Inappropriate ODP Content Here ONLY.
If a site should not be listed give us the category url (clickable link please) and the site (title as shown in DMOZ) and why you think there is something wrong.

Dirtydisco · Oct 22, 2005

Alucard said:
Dirtydisco,

The one site that you highlighted is obviously a page that is no longer available, and I have removed it from the directory - thank you very much for the heads-up! (It won't disppear from the search results until they are updated, which might take a while.)

Thanks for looking into it .

Questionable link

Dirtydisco

Member

wjcampbe

Member

Dirtydisco

Member

wjcampbe

Member

Alucard

Member

pvgool

kEditall/kCatmv

Dirtydisco

Member