Submission Question

Dwiea

Member
Joined
Jun 1, 2005
Messages
2
I was just wondering if there is anyway to tell if your submission is rejected by DMOZ, I work for a small webdesign company and have submitted almost 13 websites in different categories to DMOZ for clients since January this year and not a single one of them has been listed. I would love to know if im doing something wrong but i feel they were put in the right categories and obvioulsy i can't ask status of particular sites because of the new rules.

Is there anyway to find out? because 0 sites listed out of 13 in 6 months seems makes it seem a bit pointless to even bother submitting here.
 

jimnoble

DMOZ Meta
Joined
Mar 26, 2002
Messages
18,915
Location
Southern England
If they are the sort of websites that we list then, in time, they'll be listed.

We don't decline websites on a whim, we decline them for a reason - which is usually to do with inadequate unique content.

Submitting sites with poor descriptions or to the wrong category doesn't cause rejection - it can add delay though.

Best thing to do is be patient, concentrate on other means of promotion and further enhancing the websites' values to the surfer.
 

hutcheson

Curlie Meta
Joined
Mar 23, 2002
Messages
19,136
Whether or not the sites were put in the right categories (and most submittals, the vast majority, AREN'T) won't affect whether the sites are listed. At most, it'll affect how long it takes them -- the first editor will move them to a better category; when they get to the right category, then they'll be reviewed for a listing.

Of course, you have to consider what kind of websites you're designing. A small design company that does websites for local small businesses and organizations and might submit lots of sites. There's a good chance SOME of them will be listed quickly, but you never know -- there's no predicting.

The problem with web design companies is that (like lawyers) when they don't have legitimate business they have ways of stirring up business, and all of society is hurt. With web design companies, the temptation is to break their own basic "here's who we are and here's what we do for money" into fifty-seven flavors of "and here's another thing we do for money" sites -- fraternal mirror spam, pure and simple. Or alternatively "no, we won't tell you who we are, and we won't tell you who THEY are, but SOMEONE SOMEWHERE is willing to do THIS for money, and if you give us your money we'll go looking for someone to do it for you." -- doorway/affiliate/dropship/lead-generation/ad-banner spam pure and simple.

Either of the latter approaches will give a company a reputation as, um, "unhelpful" -- and then, if they ever WANT to make a useful suggestion, we won't care to hear it because we've already figured out we're better off without their help.
 
This site has been archived and is no longer accepting new content.
Top