Submitting 1 site to multiple catagories - is there a limit?

ralbion

Member
Joined
Feb 19, 2004
Messages
30
Hi,

I'm curious to know whether there is a limit to the number of catagories a site can be submitted to. Provided the catagories are all relevant to the site, is there any limit? And for that matter, can a site have listings in multiple catagories? (I'm assuming these are 2 different questions, since it might be the case that once a site is accepted in a catagory it can no longer be accepted in another?). I understand that re-submitting to the SAME catagory can damage your chances of acceptance, hence the query.

Hope someone can clear this up for me.

Kind regards.
 

kokopeli

kEditall/kCatmv
Curlie Meta
Joined
Jul 28, 2002
Messages
4,256
[reply removed]

Jim was faster than me posting. Nevermind ;) he said it well.
 

Alucard

Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2002
Messages
5,920
ok, here is the "full" answer as to how it works... (I'm going to deal with some special cases that the others haven't and I wrote all this when there were no other answers in the thread)

First, the number of categories a particular site can be submitted to bears no relation to the number of categories where a site can be listed. For the first, there are hard rules, for the other, it is left up to the reviewing editor's discretion. (Many assume that they are one and the same thing, which is not the case).

So, you are concerned with submissions, here are the rules.

This first part applies if your site is written in the English language only, and is not directly aimed at Kids and Teens:

Think of the directory as having two "parts" or "branches" (this is oversimplifying it, I know) - the "Regional" and "Topical" branches. By Regional, I mean any category under http://dmoz.org/Regional By "Topical", I mean any of the other parts under http://dmoz.org/

If the site has Regional focus (i.e. it is for a business that has a true "brick and mortar" location) which is obvious from the web site, then navigate down as far as possible to get the category for the town/city/village where the business is located. Then, if there are subcategories, try to find one that best fits the business or the nature of the site. You may make ONE suggestion in that category. If the site or business does not have an obvious regional focus, then no submission is possible in this branch of the tree.

Now on to the Topical part of the tree. You are allowed to make ONE submission somewhere in there - and this will depend so much on the nature of the site that I can't really give you guidelines. I would suggest you read the "Description" link at the top of each of the other branches to see which one your site best fits. Then navigate down as far as you can, reading the "Descriptions" for each category, as available, and make a submission there. Note that some types of businesses (Real Estate companies would be one example) are considered inherantly just regional in nature and do not qualify for a Topical listing.

Clear as mud so far? Then I will complicate matters further (and then make things a lot easier!). :eek:

For each language other than English that the site is written in, you will need to go and look in the "World" part of the directory to find each language. Some of the languages have their own "Regional" and "Topical" breakdowns, in which case apply the same rules as for the English category.

If the site is specifically geared towards Kids and Teens, then you need to read the Description at the head of that branch to see the requirements, and do the same navigation down to the lowest possible category.

To summarise - here is the most a site should ever be submitted to:
Somewhere under http://dmoz.org/Regional - once
Somewhere under http://dmoz.org/ that isn't World or K&T or Regional - once
Somewhere under http://dmoz.org/World - twice for each language that the site is written in other than English
Somewhere under http://dmoz.org/Kids_and_Teens/ if the site is geared exclusively to that audience.

Complicated, huh? Well, I promised I would make it simpler....

If you make ONE suggestion, and do the best job you can to find the best category for it, editors will make the call as to whether it is the most appropriate category, and move it or duplicate it accordingly.

Hope this helps.
 

ralbion

Member
Joined
Feb 19, 2004
Messages
30
Thank you moderators for your time and effort.

Ok, would you mind doing a search in Dmoz.org for "rustic blue"? The results show 5 different catagories. 2 are American-related and have no relevance to this. The other 3 all contain listings for a site called rusticblue[dot]com, one of which even has 3 different listings for the same site! (although for different urls) How is this possible? I'm confused...

Please understand I'm not trying to catch you out or anything, I'm just wondering what they've done to achieve all these listings! Is it such a great site?!

Regards.

Edit: Sorry, I'm talking rubbish, it's in 3 catagories:

Regional: Europe: Spain: Autonomous Communities: Andalucia: Travel and Tourism: Travel Services

Regional: Europe: Spain: Autonomous Communities: Andalucia: Travel and Tourism: Lodging: Hotels

Sports: Equestrian: Vacations and Touring: Europe: Spain
 

Alucard

Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2002
Messages
5,920
ralbion, that was why I took pains to point out that number of submissions have nothing to do with number of listings.

It is purely the editor's discretion how many times a site (or pages from the site) can be listed and in which category.

Does that make sense?
 
This site has been archived and is no longer accepting new content.
Top