status of www.smartplasticsurgery.com

[alekos]

I am checking on the status of http://www.smartplasticsurgery.com submitted to http://dmoz.org/Health/Medicine/Surgery/Cosmetic_and_Plastic/Patient_Education/

 

Hoping to hear it's in line for review.

Thanks for any help!

Laura

[kokopeli]

Your site was evaluated on several different occasions by several different editors and found to offer the same information as other sites listed in that section of the directory (sites must offer unique content to be listed). Your site was denied for that reason.

[alekos]

Thanks for the fast response. Would it be appropriate to submit a specific page on my site that does have unique content to another category?

 

For example, could I submit

http://www.smartplasticsurgery.com/blepharoplasty.html to http://www.dmoz.org/Health/Medicine/Surgery/Cosmetic_and_Plastic/Patient_Education/Eye/?

 

Thanks again for your help!

Laura

[John_Caius]

If your complete domain was not considered to have enough unique content to be listed then it would be very unlikely that deeplinks would be accepted.

 

<edit>This is a generally applicable point, but now see below.</edit>

[John_Caius]

I have now re-reviewed your site and its previous edit history. In my opinion the site is an excellent resource and definitely worthy of a listing. It may be the case that the site content has improved significantly since it was last reviewed or this may just be one of those situations where different editors have different opinions on a particular site. In this instance, I edit higher up the category tree than the editors who previously deleted your submission. I have therefore taken the decision to list your site in the category Patient Education and have contacted those editors to update them. It should appear on the public side in the next day or two. <img src="/images/icons/grin.gif" alt="" />

[alekos]

Thanks so much for your help! I really appreciate it!!

Have a great day!

Laura